MAYBELLINEHyper Easy Liquid Pen No-Skip Eyeliner, Satin Finish, Waterproof Formula, Pitch Black, 0.018 Fl Oz

I've wore liquid eyeliner for 24 years and tried all kinds this one for the win! Lasts through sweat, sleep, and long days. It does not smudge or rub away accidentally, but will wash off with water. The tip is perfect for straight lines and doesn't end up all over. Easy to use and the color is great. It was small and light when I first used it so I thought it might not work well, but it's amazing! No eye or skin irritation and I am sensitive to a lot of things. Picture is after a long day running around work and it still looks nice.

This eyeliner is so sleek and smooth. I really enjoyed how hassle free it is. It is good for beginners! It has really helped me get my practice in. It stays on all day and does not smear on your eyelid. It works great with eyeshadow and doesn't keep the eyeshadow on the pen.

Still have it after a year great quality long lasting and easy use

This liner is pretty excellent for the price. I used to use Kat Von D, but I ain't got that money anymore. Even if I did, I'd keep using this over the fancier brands. In humid Florida it holds well if you use something to set your eyelids first. Which means if you live somewhere dry? You are set my friend.My eye area tends to get sweaty, and maybe by the end of a 6-8 hour day in humid summer it'll start smudging a teensy bit. By then I'm generally at home. It can be difficult to remove---I use oil to massage it off my skin, and then soap my face. And even then I might still have some residue that a face tonic easily rids of. Worth the work for how good it lasts. Easy to draw, the color is DARK and you only really need one layer. It's comfy and glides on well and doesn't bleed. I have hooded eyes so I have to keep my eyes closed for it to dry first, as with all liquid liner. Only downside? The brush tip bleeds a bit. Like, it bubbles out the product and I have to clear it off with a napkin. Otherwise, the felt tip is soooo saturated that my lines get smudged or it'll apply too much product. I've had it for a while now, and so perhaps being tossed around in my purse has made it sad. It hasn't exploded though and still works rather well. I feel I've used it so much and it doesn't seem to plan on drying anytime soon.

I’ve tried a lot of liquid eyeliners, and this one really impressed me. The pen tip is super precise, so it’s perfect for beginners or anyone who struggles with winged liner. It glides on smoothly without skipping, and the formula is very black and dries quickly. I also love that it doesn’t smudge or fade during the day—it actually stays put until I take it off. If you want something easy to use that gives clean lines every time, this one is a great pick. I’ve already repurchased it.

I've been testing out various pen liners so I can change up brands. I've used NYX frequently and wanted to switch it up since my pen finally died. I will admit I'm a makeup snob especially when it comes to eye makeup. I however hate paying the eye cost that's associated with some of the brand names when some off brand products or "drug store" type products work just as well. This is my first time buying Maybelline's eyeliner and I doubt I'll buy it again. What I do like is the fine tip point and the black color. It went on easily and the tip is great. My complaint has to do with if you line your top lid. I've attempted lining with both primer and without and the results were the same regardless. The top lid continues to smear or fade away faster then the bottom and wings. The bottom I didn't notice that so much but I also go over my eyeliner a lot of times with shadow under my eye. This product smears easier than other products. I use a setting spray and even then I rubbed near my eye and had black streaking. Normally my setting spray prevents that or other brands stay on longer. I mean it's ok in a pinch and if you line your eyes with shadow over the liner on the lids but for me, this is a pass for going out or needing something long-lasting.I've tried out a cheaper brand non-brand name that worked better which surprised me after seeing the great reviews on this product. I'll go back to NYX, Too faced and other brands mainly because I line my top lid and need something that works there as well. If sticking with this brand make sure you have a setting spray and eye primer or maybe just use for under your eyes.

i'm always testing eyeliners and I would say this one is really good. I like the price It's pretty good for that and I like that it stays on. It's not too much waterproof, but I still like it a lot more than a lot of eyeliners that I have.

I love this liner!!!! I have hooded eyes that tend to be a bit oily - you know, you apply liner and then you see it like a tatoo on your upper eyelid - not quite the look. Well, that's what happens when I use a pencil. I can not control the size or density of the line when I use a pencil. But, this liner - with the felt tip - flawless application! With just a light touch, I place the tip at my inner eye and glide, yes, effortlessly glide across my eye, add a little more pressure to widen the liner line. Once it dries, it does not smudge off like a pencil can. The color is a dark brown, maybe with a tint of black. a perfect color when I do not want a dramatic black cat eye.